The book is a collection of essays that explore the connections between sports, culture and the Christian faith. From that standpoint the chapters don't build on one another, but in many ways stand on their own. Kluck admits that much of what we see in sports is not admirable, and leaves the Christian to wonder whether we should engage with our culture on this front or not. More than anything Kluck seeks to engage his readers on how Christians should view sports, better said how sports should be funneled through our Christian faith and though the book is not extensive in his exploration of this question, he leaves the reader wanting more, though certainly making one aware of new paths to explore.
His perspective was refreshing in places as he pulled quotes from stars such as Tom Brady and Tony Mandarich, men who are not Christians, who expressed an Ecclesiastes perspective on life, success, and fame. At one point he reminds his readers, "Christian sportswriters can write about non-Christian athletes in a way that still upholds the gospel and makes people think about Christ." Though not expressed, I would think the challenge with this approach is that so few believers see the world through a gospel lens, allowing it to show up in places we rarely would find it. That's where this book was so refreshing, it reminds us that the gospel can be seen even where we least expect it.
Kluck's insights on Mike Tyson and Ricky Williams were needed and should give any fan a warning about cheering or making smug comments at an athlete's demise whether on or off the field. Both of these men are extremely flawed, yet they both express such awareness of their own depravity that never seems to be expressed by a Christian athlete.
Be aware that Kluck comes down pretty strong against so-called Christian athletes, mentioning Dwight Howard as one example of someone who takes the label, but who often fall into very public sin. Kluck seems to suggest he'd rather a Christian not be as public about their faith, but simply be real. I couldn't help but say an "amen" to this point. As a child I read Sports Spectrum and can't tell you the number of guys on the cover who have had very public falls or show character on or off the field that seems contrary to their affirmation that they are a follower of Christ.
In addition, Kluck comes down hard against Christian films and books (I told you some of the sections were random!) Though some of his critique is cinematic in nature, much of what he takes issue with is this cycle that they typically use that shows initial faith, wayward/rebellious years, hitting some form of rock bottom, greater commitment to the Lord, great rewards (new contract, super bowl win). The books continue to be sold, movies made that use that type of cycle. Here's the problem, life doesn't always work out that way and God isn't on the hook if He doesn't provide a super bowl or beautiful wife to the Christian athlete. That's not grace nor the Christian faith. Instead, Kluck points to a movie like Chariots of Fire and displays how the characters are all wrestling with meaning and purpose and seeking to find it in different places.
Finally, Kluck argues that sports are good, but must be compartmentalized, that is that they have a place. Sports are a gateway for men to have relationships. Whether that's at a surface level about fantasy football, a deep and rich level that a father and son find through practices and games, or whether that's a friendship that bridges racial, social, or even religious divides, sports provide that opportunity for guys to engage with other guys. I can't help but agree, my favorite and best moments with my dad are centered around watching, playing, and talking about sports and all the conversations that are spun from those discussions. I've made friendships with guys with whom I shared nothing, but a desire to win or desire to see our team win. This is a great book with a great message for men and the way we view sports.
